Comments on Guys Where Are We? | LOST Theories and Ideas: Revelation! UPDATED

Nice connection to the whole smoke detector thing....

2009-05-20T11:31:45.092-07:00

Nice connection to the whole smoke detector thing. :)

Ah yes, see what you mean. I also just realized th...

2009-05-20T10:16:17.679-07:00

Ah yes, see what you mean. I also just realized that if Christian was being impersonated by "Esau" then he was responsible for beckoning Claire into the woods.

Allison, sorry, when I said "playing him" I meant ...

2009-05-20T08:22:02.963-07:00

Allison, sorry, when I said "playing him" I meant like conning him, not taking over his body. I think there evidence that Richard could be unintentionally working for him, or basically just playing right into his hands without realizing it.

I'm not sure if Richard was ever really "Esau" pla...

2009-05-19T22:09:48.204-07:00

I'm not sure if Richard was ever really "Esau" playing Richard or not. Especially because he told "Blocke" which IS Esau, that "I'm this way (meaning ageless) because of Jacob." So he'd essentially be talking to someone he once impersonated. Also, we've never been given any indication that Richard Alpert died. It seems as though the theory about "Esau" taking over impersonating someone calls for a dead body.

Haha. We've been using "Esau" as well, although, I...

2009-05-15T14:47:00.000-07:00

Haha. We've been using "Esau" as well, although, I think he's Alvar Hanso, and I'm determined to find proof of it somewhere! The bit about Smokey destroying the statue totally sounds like it could be right!

Smokey must be controlled by Esau/Blocke/Alvar, as almost everything smokey seems to play into his plans. Also when Alvar was parading around as Christian Shepard and he appeared to Jack at the hospital waiting room, Jack was having to fix the smoke detector. FORESHADOW ALERT!!

Jen what episode is that hieroglyphics with smokey...

2009-05-15T13:39:00.000-07:00

Jen what episode is that hieroglyphics with smokey and the statue? Also referring to Ben just being a pawn, its amazing how the dynamics of LOST can change so quickly.

And haha I love it "Blocke" let's use that from now on.

P.S. Now I feel bad for Ben. The man who started ...

2009-05-15T13:34:00.000-07:00

P.S. Now I feel bad for Ben. The man who started off as seemingly the most powerful man on the island proved to be nothing more than a pawn. But the reason I feel bad is I really thought Smokey was playing the moral police with the visions of Alex. Now I'm thinking it was all a ploy to get Ben mentally right where Blocke (Bad Locke) wanted him.

So is that why Smokey spared John's life back a fe...

2009-05-15T13:26:00.000-07:00

So is that why Smokey spared John's life back a few seasons ago? Cause it was all part of the plan?

Also, I'm reminded of the heiroglyphics of Smokey and the Statue looking like they were fighting each other. Was it Smokey that destroyed the statue in hopes of destroying Jacob? Me and Justin have affectionately referred to the man in black as "Esau" until we know his name.

Comments on Guys Where Are We? | LOST Theories and Ideas: Revelation! *UPDATED*